Like

Digging Deeper

Elijah Sullivan, the Hole Story…

When Elijah Sullivan started making his documentary about a local unsolved crime, he thought he was going to solve the mystery. “The movie is about the discovery of a 60-foot hole on Mount Shasta that became an urban legend in an area already filled with urban legends,” he says. “I caught it at the moment where the facts were starting to become forgotten and the speculation was becoming the story.”

For Sullivan, the bizarre tale surrounding “the hole” offered a way into a larger story about the community he was raised in. “I’ve always wanted to do a movie about Mount Shasta, but it’s such a vast, complex subject that I didn’t have a good frame for it,” he says. “I needed something that could contain the crazy but was still watchable.”

Like many locals, Sullivan had an immediate theory about what had happened. “The first thing I thought was what most locals thought, which was that if we tell stories about an ancient civilization beneath the mountain, somebody would eventually show up with a shovel and go looking for it,” he says. “It ended up being a lot more complicated than that.”

Photos courtesy of Elijah Sullivan

That complication became Sullivan’s feature-length documentary entitled “The Hole Story,” and a 10-year effort to understand how stories take root and shape a community. “When I started the movie, I really thought I was going to get to the bottom of it—forgive the pun—and bring the truth out,” he says. “I thought I was going to be able to get certain things on the record, and it would be this bombshell thing.” Instead, the film became more human. “What I ended up getting was more of an oral history, where people described their personal involvement,” Sullivan says. “Not all of the facts meshed. That pointed toward a different question about why people remember things in certain ways and what that says about them. Why do people believe what they believe? What needs are their beliefs fulfilling, and what are they choosing to ignore?”

Sullivan came to see that those questions reached far beyond his hometown. “I grew up in a community where fringe belief is embraced, and everybody is encouraged to be themselves, maybe even to a fault,” he says. “Then, watching what goes on in the world, I realized that this is happening everywhere.” That realization also helped shape the film’s restrained style. Sullivan does not appear or narrate, and he rarely resolves contradictions. “I tried to let people talk and tell their stories,” he says. “I let it be complicated and messy, rather than turn it into a comedy about people with funny hats or a sensationalistic thriller. The story speaks for itself.”

Bringing that story home proved intimidating. When it opened locally, the film played during the final 10 days of Mount Shasta Cinemas, where Sullivan once worked. “It was bittersweet,” he says. “It was a dual celebration of seeing Mount Shasta on the screen, but it was also saying goodbye to our movie theater.” It was also a huge success. In a town of roughly 3,200 people, the film sold more than 1,000 tickets in 10 days. “It’s pretty mind-boggling to me,” Sullivan says. “It would be such an honor if it stuck around in the cultural memory for a little while.”

So far, the film has received huge acclaim on the independent film festival circuit, with a highly coveted acceptance to Slamdance Film Festival in Park City, Utah, where “The Hole Story” was among a handful of films selected from 9,000 or so submissions. “I submitted to Slamdance thinking I was going to get rejected and should just get that out of the way. Then I got accepted, which blew my mind, and everything has been a blur since.” That blur has included other notable screenings at festivals like the Ashland Independent Film Festival and The Big Sky Documentary Film Festival, among others. It was even featured on NPR’s “This American Life.”

Photos courtesy of Elijah Sullivan

The film’s overall reception far eclipsed the project Sullivan first imagined when he heard about “the hole” over drinks with friends in 2012. “I was immediately obsessed with it,” he recalls. “I knew how to file a FOIA request, and I knew a little about film production. I figured the people I’m interviewing are all in my community. The crime scene is up the street from my house. I thought maybe it would take me a summer.”

Instead, the project became a 14-year-plus odyssey of patience, resourcefulness and determination. But in the end, the creation of the film only cost Sullivan $700 out-of-pocket. It cost a lot more in sweat equity. “I started this in my late 20s, and I’m now 41,” Sullivan says. “There were individual shots where I’d spend three days getting the right shot of a lenticular cloud. I spent years filming clouds. I have terabytes of footage of clouds.”

Sullivan is ready to start another project, but doubts he’ll ever let go of the mystery that first inspired him. “As obsessed as I am with this story, I’m sure I’ll never stop,” he says with a laugh. “But whatever I make next, I’m sure it won’t be made far from here. After this, it’s much easier to tell myself I’m a filmmaker. I’ve done it, and I can do it from where I live. I don’t have to move to Hollywood.”•

About Megan Peterson

Megan Peterson is a freelance storyteller who loves her family, her pets, and Northern California. Her favorite part of writing is finding flow, and she always relishes a touching human story. Aside from Enjoy, she’s typically busy writing and producing for television, having created more than 220 hours of on-air content on networks ranging from National Geographic to Netflix.

Related Posts